The Anti-Cinderella Campaign

Anti-Cinderella.” — I was engaged in a conversation with an American UN Peace Corps Volunteer for Education in my high school alma mater when I first heard of this term. She, an enthusiastic woman whose advocacy is creative writing, was relating to me how surprised she was to find that storytelling activities at the high school level still involved telling the story of Cinderella.

We’re kind of anti-Cinderella,” she explained. “We don’t want to promote the idea that you need a prince to save you from misery and make it in life.”

 

When I first heard the term at that time —anti-Cinderella— I must admit, I felt a wee bit part of me die somehow. You can imagine the princess-wannabe part of me—that part ingrained and nurtured by so many princess fairy tales I read and Disney-princess movies I watched as a child—reacting to the term with a downhearted, “But I love Cinderella…” said complete with a cutesy voice and puppy-dog eyes.

How could some people now be attaching the prefix “anti” to such a classic hallmark of any girl’s childhood role models?

But then, of course, the more I thought of it, the more it made sense. As a character, Cinderella was docile and gentle, content to slaving away for the sake of a family she clearly didn’t think she should go up against even when she was mistreated.

If you really examine the tale’s plot, you’ll see Cinderella owed her happily-ever-after to a generous fairy godmother, a dashing prince charming, and a friendly group of mice.

Thus Cinderella was the typical damsel-in-distress, I-need-a-hero, I’m-even-prettier-when-I-weep kind of character found in many fairy tales told to young girls who then grow up idealizing this image. The underlying theme is that meekness and kind-heartedness will, in due time, be inevitably rewarded with a happy-ever-after—just you wait and be patient; your time will come.

Image by Sofi [http://www.flickr.com/photos/sofi01/] via Flickr [http://www.flickr.com/photos/sofi01/4369517421/] CC BY-NC 2.0 [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/]

Image by Sofi via Flickr CC BY-NC 2.0

Now, this is a hopeful view—in no way are meekness and kind-heartedness evil traits to possess, and certainly every girl desires a happy-ever-after (spent with a handsome prince to boot) in this life.

The only problem is, life is not a fairy tale. And discovering this is bound to be a heartbreak for young girls who’ve grown up to think that they are or will be princesses, and are entitled to be treated by the world as so.

What happens, then, when the plot thickens and evil stepmothers and bad witches and dragons descend upon them? They await a fairy godmother to pop out of thin air, a knight in shining armor to slay the dragons and rescue them, or a prince on a white horse to deliver them from injustice (and marry them, of course).

When none of the above “saviors” come, the unprepared girl may weep, become despondent, give up, or simply lay helpless, enduring whatever fire the dragon breathes on them. Tsk, tsk, tsk, not such a good ending to what could’ve been a great story.

 ♠

When we think about adversity and the bravery it requires to come out on top of whatever challenge is up, we think about heroes in the traditional sense—valiant knights in shining armor, demi-gods of Greek mythology, caped muscular men flying over cities, saving damsels in distress.

Who’s the bravest person you know?” A young girl’s answer to this question is likely to point to any of these characters—these characters she dreams of one day saving her too, instead of characters she dreams of becoming.

But it’s time for a shift in this view, and the world recognizes it. Mercy Academy, an all-girls Catholic school in Kentucky, has recently gained attention for its unique ad campaign with the tagline “Prepare for real life,” and slogans such as “You’re not a princess,” “Life’s not a fairytale,” and “Don’t wait for a prince; be able to rescue yourself.” People are calling it “the next mommy wars” —pro-Disney Princess vs. anti-Disney Princess.

Image

The 11 Official Disney Princesses
Image courtesy of wikia.com CC-BY-SA

I, personally, would like to cast my vote for the anti-Disney Princess side. Only, there’s this one thing: Of the eleven official Disney Princesses, there’s one who neither was born into the title (i.e., not the daughter of a King or a Chieftain) nor has married a prince to gain the title Princess — Fa Mulan.

Mulan is (to date) the only Disney Princess to not hold the title of Princess in one form or another; not noble born, she bears no titles of her own, although she earns the non-noble title of Imperial Consul. Her eventual marriage to General Li Shang (also non-noble) does not grant her any titles either. — wikia.com

 

Mulan is one of the bravest fictional characters I know, and my favorite Disney “Princess.” But it was only when I saw this particular internet meme that I recognized how truly different she is from the other Disney princesses:

Image courtesy of weknowmemes.com [http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/why-mulan-was-clearly-the-best-disney-princess.jpg]

Image courtesy of weknowmemes.com

Mulan is a role model whose cunning and bravery are worth underscoring, especially to young girls who are still learning what society thinks is ideal, praiseworthy, and worth pursuing. What Mulan made of her life and how she fulfilled her mission, she did not owe to any fairy godmother instantly giving her everything she needed with the wave of a wand (in fact, her guardian Mushu, though helpful, had caused her a few more troubles than were necessary along the way). She was not rescued by a dashing young prince; she saved her General in an unhesitating act of combined courage and concern. She did not wait for a hero; she decided to become one.

 

“If there are no heros to save you, then you be the hero.” — Denpa Kyoshi

 

Thus I am officially joining the anti-Disney-Princess-except-Mulan bandwagon. It’s time we raise a generation of young girls who do not just dream of becoming princesses, but aim at becoming warrior-princesses, ready to take up the sword and fight if necessary…

 

…the kind guided but not passively bound by tradition and conformity, not afraid to break a few rules along the way for the sake of heroic sacrifice and nobility…

 

…and able to think for themselves

and act to be the hero of their own story…

…such that when they’re asked,

Who’s the bravest person you know?,

they need not look far.

They can simply look in the mirror, find a courageous fire reflected in their eyes, and their answer shall unhesitatingly be,

♦ “I am.” ♦

¨

» • • • «

wanderrgirl-blogging-challenge

» • • • «

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The Anti-Cinderella Campaign

  1. A great topic. I’m questioning what to get my two five year old nieces for Christmas. I don’t want to contribute to the inundation they get everyone where around them to find strength outside themselves, but I also don’t want to irritate my sisters/their mothers by refusing to give them something “non-traditional”!

  2. Your catholic school has an even bigger fairy tale than Cinderella and the Virgen Mary might be included.
    I have often wondered the evolutionary roles of males and females on humankind. Add to the story of Cinderella that she used her female tears to gain control of the kingdom and subjugate all the evil bullies (witches, step sisters and step mothers). One reads into the story what one wants. Next we go after Wiley Coyote to find the road runner is a woman?

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s